Training question?
Moderators: Roguelet, hpkingjr, WaveMaster, madelyn
But we're definitley not numbing... THAT'S CALLED NERVE BLOCKING
there are plenty of topical anagelsics that work b/c they numb the area to an extent. Plain ice will do that. I'm not being argumentative here but the fact is
a) you are using these product to eliminate the "sting" associated with track surface.
b) To eliminate the "sting" you have to use a product that will essentially completely or partially reduce feeling sensation to the hoof.
You are right in that it probably doesn't work. I understand the fact that a lot of TB's today have really horrible feet, and partially this is genetic but to a larger extent its the environment on which its raised (i.e shoes put on too young).
If a horse is tender footed a thin leather pad to protect its sole without compromising the feeling to any other parts of the hoof/ leg. That way the horse knows where its feet are underneath him, and will feel any source soreness potentially preventing a bigger problem from occuring.
I guess I've gone the roundabout way of saying...why do it if it doesn't work? If it does work, isn't that the same thing as saying that you are "masking pain" or "numbing" that area?
"I think animal testing is a terrible idea; they get all nervous and give the wrong answers."
The first trainer I had always used Turpentine. The shed-row stunk of it. He said it was great for the legs and feet. anyone know why ? I never did figure it out.
Venice Turpentine has a variety of uses as a counter irritant to promote circulation (thus helping with new hoof growth/healing injury), it is said that it relieves soreness associated with a variety of hoof ailments/strenuous exercise. My farrier uses it as a simple hoof dressing/pack stating it prevents quarter cracks and toughens up the feet.
"I think animal testing is a terrible idea; they get all nervous and give the wrong answers."
-
- Allowance Winner
- Posts: 445
- Joined: Thu Sep 16, 2004 7:34 pm
- Location: Sandy Spring, MD
- Contact:
Ever tried to tell an old timer what they're doing is wrong? I was taught by an old timer. It doesn't hurt the horse, it might not work (we'll never know- horses can't talk), it might help. Who knows. Until then... I'll be using hoof freeze AND ice boots on the day of the race. (until someone comes up with something that they can logically explain and it makes sense to me)
Racing and retraining.
Thank you katydid for the answer. The old trainers used to use all kinds of wierd stuff, but a lot of it makes sense and is replaced by more modern things that do the same thing. He was a big fan of blistering and pin-firing also. I was never real enthused about the pin firing for bucked shins. I changed the fellow who broke my horses and none of them buck now, so I don't have to even deal with that issue and I'm glad.
-
- Breeder's Cup Winner
- Posts: 2212
- Joined: Thu Sep 16, 2004 8:46 pm
xfactor fan wrote:Wouldn't soaking feet in any sort of water tend to soften the hoof?
Thats why "icing" a horse's legs and freezing the feet by painting foot freeze on are 2 entirely separate things. Foot freeze DOES work in my definition but if you define "work" by achieving a completely numb hoof then no, it doesnt work. It just reduces the sting.
- Tucumcari
- Chef de Race: Brilliant
- Posts: 3754
- Joined: Fri Mar 18, 2005 11:51 am
- Location: Here and there
Those of you who oppose hoof freeze are giving entirely too much credit to the products we use as hoof freeze. As someone else stated blocking a foot and useing hoof freeze are two very different things.
Hoof freeze will never reduce feeling enough to impair the horse's ability to put it's feet down.. ever. Track surfaces are hard and cause a sting in the foot, even during every day training. Foot freeze just helps the horse feel more comfortable.
It is common practice for trainers to pack a horse's feet for days prior to running in a race. Using icthamol, magna paste, mud (poultice), etc, to draw any heat due to the rigors of training out of the foot. The foot is a bad place to have heat as all things expand with heat unfortunately the hoof is the one part of the horse's body that is incapable of expanding... So it is in the horse's best interest to draw any heat out of the foot... Trainers use shoes such as no-vibes that have pads to help reduce the concussion the foot has to incur. But that only goes so far as the psi of the hoof during full flight is high...
We all use hoof freeze or some form of it. It isn't harmful to the horse and it doesn't enhance performance. It is safe and done for years. How well it works, who knows... God knows how much of the stuff I have had on my hands over the years and I have never felt anthing in the way of freezing on my skin, it's just an ugly stain that doesn't readily go away...
Hoof freeze will never reduce feeling enough to impair the horse's ability to put it's feet down.. ever. Track surfaces are hard and cause a sting in the foot, even during every day training. Foot freeze just helps the horse feel more comfortable.
It is common practice for trainers to pack a horse's feet for days prior to running in a race. Using icthamol, magna paste, mud (poultice), etc, to draw any heat due to the rigors of training out of the foot. The foot is a bad place to have heat as all things expand with heat unfortunately the hoof is the one part of the horse's body that is incapable of expanding... So it is in the horse's best interest to draw any heat out of the foot... Trainers use shoes such as no-vibes that have pads to help reduce the concussion the foot has to incur. But that only goes so far as the psi of the hoof during full flight is high...
We all use hoof freeze or some form of it. It isn't harmful to the horse and it doesn't enhance performance. It is safe and done for years. How well it works, who knows... God knows how much of the stuff I have had on my hands over the years and I have never felt anthing in the way of freezing on my skin, it's just an ugly stain that doesn't readily go away...
- sulphurfire
- Allowance Winner
- Posts: 370
- Joined: Sat Nov 06, 2004 5:33 pm
- Location: southwest louisiana
- Contact:
Not to be disagreeable, but they do expand. Ask a farrier....the hoof is the one part of the horse's body that is incapable of expanding...
Does Venice turpentine kill the nerve endings in your fingers if you spill it?
And thou fly without wings, and conquer without any sword. Oh, horse. - The Qur'an