http://www.pedigreequery.com/clabber+girl
Anyone care to analyze this pedigee?
clabber girl analysis
Moderators: Roguelet, hpkingjr, WaveMaster, Lucy
clabber girl analysis
Last edited by Derring on Mon Jan 23, 2006 7:27 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"Animals are such agreeable friends--they ask no questions, they pass no criticisms."
-----George Eliot
-----George Eliot
Hi Derring,
Look at the race and production record of Genuine Risk and Wonders Delight (only 2 examples). Look at Cheyenne Birdsong's production and then that of her daughers. If I could answer it in a post I could command $10,000/hr
. This is a site that puts a lot of emphasis on 'paper' breedings. They have their place but there's a lot more involved.
I commented (elsewhere) about Solvig, a G3 winner in foal to Smarty Jones (sold for $950k) was to be bred to Afleet Alex this year. With a War Chant and Giant's Causeway on the ground she's been bred to 4 stallions that are either unproven or lack sustained proof of success. Every one was unproven when they bred to her and their fees high.
If Solvig is a successful mare it will be in spite of her connections who have made her ability to prove herself more difficult than it needed to be. Commercially she will carry an unproven stallion but not forever.
They could have chosen Pulpit (look at a hypo mating - female tails to Missy Baba), Dynaformer, Smart Strike etc. in the same price range to give her the best chance of showing her worth, retaining the value of the mare and seeing her real quality.
Regards,
Pete
Look at the race and production record of Genuine Risk and Wonders Delight (only 2 examples). Look at Cheyenne Birdsong's production and then that of her daughers. If I could answer it in a post I could command $10,000/hr
. This is a site that puts a lot of emphasis on 'paper' breedings. They have their place but there's a lot more involved.
I commented (elsewhere) about Solvig, a G3 winner in foal to Smarty Jones (sold for $950k) was to be bred to Afleet Alex this year. With a War Chant and Giant's Causeway on the ground she's been bred to 4 stallions that are either unproven or lack sustained proof of success. Every one was unproven when they bred to her and their fees high.
If Solvig is a successful mare it will be in spite of her connections who have made her ability to prove herself more difficult than it needed to be. Commercially she will carry an unproven stallion but not forever.
They could have chosen Pulpit (look at a hypo mating - female tails to Missy Baba), Dynaformer, Smart Strike etc. in the same price range to give her the best chance of showing her worth, retaining the value of the mare and seeing her real quality.
Regards,
Pete
Has a palomino jean that pop up some.
This stallion is DNA ... all foal can be MBNA inrolled.
Horses like their credit cards. - Four Forty Farms
This stallion is DNA ... all foal can be MBNA inrolled.
Horses like their credit cards. - Four Forty Farms